Cat lover who TNRed 20+ stray cats confronted by cat lady for ‘stealing’ her fur babies

Author image for Laurent Shinar
Laurent Shinar • Writer and Editor
Oct 17, 2026 2:15 PM EDT

The subject of what to do with stray cat populations is a contentious one and this story spells out a significant part of the problem surrounding the topic. There are many opinions of what is best to do, but ultimately laws, resources and the luck of having hoomans who are willing to help dictate what happens in reality. Which is how our story begins in a country where TNR is illegal and with a cat lover who took it upon themselves to trap, spay and put more than 20 cats up for adoption. Setting them up in a safe shelter until their furever home comes along. But when this thoughtful hooman was confronted by a local cat lady who was convinced our reducer was 'stealing' her cat children, well, the whole story took a turn for the strange. It turns out this woman had been hoarding these street cats in her home trying to fill the hole left in her heart when her husband had passed.

The woman was understandably attached to the kitties. After all, it is all too well known that when people happen to lose someone they often replace them, or at least attempt to do so with the introduction of a cat child. And while many do so with only one or at most two felines, there are some people with a lack of impulse control and a desperate need for warmth and love who will do things that most of us feline fans feel is unreasonable. The problem is that they do not see this for themselves. They are blinded by the intense urge to fill the void in their souls, their missing piece, and when they get a pawsitive feeling from doing so once, they are often inclined to keep doing it to get that same rush. It is a serious mental health issue and one that ultimately affects the felines for the worse as they deserve the safe, cleanliness and lack of competition that comes with living in a one or at most two cat house hold.

This story truly highlights that in our own minds and worlds as long as we are doing something, we often feel as though we are doing the right thing. But in reality the right thing can be many different things and we remain blinded to the reality of what we are doing. So if you are one of the wonderful people who do whatever they can to help cat kind, just take into account that not everyone is going to agree with your decisions. Not everyone is going to believe that your way is right, and they may be right, they may be wrong. The only responsible thing you can do in the situation is to take accountability for whatever mistakes you make come to light and remember that above all else you are trying to help the cats. The operative word being trying. So try your best and hopefully there is something for you to learn from in this story.
 

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to start your Caturday with the funniest felines on the internet!

Advertisement
  • 01
    "I live in a county where TNR is illegal."
    via KandyShopp

    Several stray cats.

    Representative only.


     

  • 02
    So, I (20F) live in a neighborhood where there are many cats wondering around. So many that we don't have birds or other small animals around usually because the cats will hunt them down to eat them. Well, because of ( I've been home enough to befriend many of these cats, and I realized many of
    via KandyShopp
  • 03
    them are adoptable pets! They seem to enjoy being pt, cooed at, etc. and as I work closely with the local shelter, I got some live traps and places them out and about to cats several. I caught 27 cats in total (3 were p t so the number is possibly higher by now) and took them to the shelter where I helped set them all up, bathed a
    via KandyShopp
  • 04
    few, etc. (Note, our shelter is a no k shelter, so there is NO danger to these cats) Well, a few days ago, when I was setting some more traps up again, an older lady from down the street comes towards me and asks "what's you think you're doing!?!" I stop and answer honestly, I'm setting up traps to help with the stray
    via KandyShopp

  • Wow, well lets start off by giving this heroic hooman a very well deserved round of applause as she has put her time and effort on the line to save the lives of so many cats! Sure, some might say that a street cat’s life is not all that bad, but when you find yourself in an area with so many street cats that the bird population is severely affected, well, that is no longer cute. That is a significant problem, and at that one that can only really be solved with TNR and adoption. When the population gets this large not only do more and more fights break out over dwindling resources, but if one cat gets unwell, then a whole heap more are likely to also get sick. 
     

  • 05
    Cheezburger Image 10670659584
    via KandyShopp
  • 06
    cat population. The traps don't hurt the cats and I'm just trying to get them adopted. The lady starts CRYING and says that those cats are her babies and how she's noticed several have gone missing and how could I have taken her babies. As an additional note, the cats weren't as bad off as
    via KandyShopp
  • 07
    many strays are, but they were all under weight, dirty, not fixed and several had upper respiratory problems (common in cats who live in large groups). I tried to console her and explained she could go adopt some from the shelter, but she just sobbed hard saying that our town only allows three cats per household, and she can't
    via KandyShopp
  • 08
    Cheezburger Image 10670659328
    via KandyShopp
  • 09
    choose which ones to keep! That's like choosing a favorite child. I haven't put any traps out since, mainly because I kind of Incan understand where she's coming from. She's a widow, and I don't think she really has family or even friends, and must be so lonely! I know that animals help with loneliness, but I also worry
    via KandyShopp
  • 10
    Cheezburger Image 10670659840
    via KandyShopp
  • 11
    for the cats safety. Not to mention the local wildlife. I tried to explain that to her but she was in hysterics by that point so I just sat down with her for a bit before picking up the traps and walking her home (where the cats seem to congregate) (Also, I live in a county where TNR is illegal, so I don't have that option)
    via KandyShopp

  • Oh jheez this is quite the complex situation. To begin with this cat lady is completely understandable. She saw a whole load of feline souls without a home and immediately took it upon herself to give them the shelter she felt they deserved. And she was not wrong, simply misguided and blinded by a her need for love, and who has not done something slightly out of place in the name of love in their life. But the fact that TNR is illegal in the poster’s country, well, that explains how this situation got so bad so quickly. There are only so many hoomans who are able to adopt cattos into their homes and at that, there are only so many spots in shelters and rescues to accommodate the stray population. 
     

  • 12
    Cheezburger Image 10670660864
    via KandyShopp
  • 13
    Edit: many are saying it might be terms of lease to only own three cats, but it's actually city ordinance limiting pets, no landlord. Update: I've decided to keep trapping the cats, the shelter has a system set up for feral cats to be "hired help" on farms where they will be fixed and sent to work on rodent populations, so I'm also trapping the feral cats as
    via KandyShopp
  • 14
    well (I was before, but several people were worried about them being either put down or being kept in cages their entire life) I'm going to talk with the shelter and see if we have any counseling for hoarders available in town. I'm also going to start trying to befriend the lady as well. Maybe not being as lonely,
    via KandyShopp
  • 15
    Cheezburger Image 10670661632
    via KandyShopp
  • 16
    she won't be as attached to the cats, and might be able to see that them leaving doesn't mean she'll end up alone. Lastly, for the few worried about pets being caught and taken (since some people do allow their cats to wonder) from the 27 caught, two had chips and were returned to their families. We also "hold" the animals for a week so if you
    via KandyShopp
  • 17
    H
    via KandyShopp
  • 18
    don't have a chip you can check the website and see what animals we have that might be yours. (Also, one of the mamas gave birth, and she had four kittens! One was sick so I'm glad I caught her since the vet was able to quickly take care of the problem and he's doing all better!) Also, nearly forgot the fur tax, so I posted some pics of some caught cats
    via KandyShopp
  • 19
    Cheezburger Image 10670660096
    via KandyShopp
  • 20
    Update 2: I know this is very late, but I did have to call authorities because the older lady had a stroke. I went to see her in the hospital and she is doing okay but is gonna move into a nursing home. (We're gonna be penpals!) and she's glad the cats are being rehomed. I guess she watched an animal planet show while in
    via KandyShopp
  • 21
    Cheezburger Image 10670660608
    via KandyShopp
  • 22
    the hospital and realized she was being harmful to the cats. I'm also helping her sign up for volunteer work once a month (mainly just socialization) and working with her nursing home to get a "seniors and seniors" where our older animals come and get some loving from the other seniors at the home.
    via KandyShopp
  • 23
    Cheezburger Image 10670660352
    via KandyShopp
  • 24
    Thank you so much to everyone for your input! I know I'm a very soft hearted person who wants to make everyone happy and seeing so many say her happiness isn't the priority here helped a lot. Thank you all so much!
    via KandyShopp
  • 25
    Cheezburger Image 10670661376
    via KandyShopp

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

stray cats stealing cat lady fur baby cat lover
Scroll Down For The Next Article